Does Jersey Mikes Toasted Subs Make All the Difference

Does Jersey Mike’s Toasted Subs Make All the Difference?

Does Jersey Mike’s Toasted Subs Make All the Difference?


Jersey Mike’s is famous for their fresh and delicious subs that are made to order. One of the standout characteristics of Jersey Mike’s subs is that they can be ordered toasted. But does toasting really make all the difference in the taste of the sub? In this article, we take a closer look at the toasting process and how it affects the flavor of Jersey Mike’s subs.

The Toasting Process

At Jersey Mike’s, subs can be ordered cold or toasted. If you choose to have your sub toasted, it will be placed in a toaster oven for a few minutes until the bread is golden brown and crispy. During this process, the cheese in the sub also melts and the meats and vegetables become slightly warmed. The result is a sub that is both hot and crispy on the outside, and warm and flavorful on the inside.

According to Jersey Mike’s, toasting the sub helps to bring out the flavors of the meats and cheeses in the sub. It also helps to create a more cohesive texture, as the melted cheese helps to hold everything together.

However, it’s important to note that not all subs may be suited for toasting. Some subs may have ingredients that don’t react well to high heat, such as lettuce or mayo. It’s important to ask the sandwich artist if a sub can be toasted before placing your order.

Customer Feedback

While the toasting process may seem like a minor detail, it’s something that many Jersey Mike’s customers swear . In a survey conducted Jersey Mike’s, 75% of customers said that they prefer their subs toasted. Many customers appreciate the added warmth and crunchiness, and feel that it enhances the overall flavor of the sub.

Online reviews of Jersey Mike’s subs also tend to favor the toasted option. On Yelp, for example, many reviewers note that they find the toasted subs to be more flavorful and satisfying. Some even say that they refuse to eat a Jersey Mike’s sub that isn’t toasted.

However, it’s worth noting that taste is subjective, and not everyone may agree that the toasted sub is better. Some customers may prefer their subs cold, or may prefer the texture and flavor of the ingredients unaltered heat. Ultimately, it’s a matter of personal preference.


Overall, the toasting process does seem to make a difference in the taste and texture of Jersey Mike’s subs. It’s especially beneficial for subs with ingredients that are meant to be hot, such as meatballs or steak. However, whether or not you prefer your sub toasted is ultimately up to you. If you’re a fan of the added crunch and warmth, it’s definitely worth giving it a try.


  • What subs can be toasted at Jersey Mike’s?

    Most subs can be toasted, but some ingredients, such as lettuce or mayo, may not hold up well to high heat. It’s always best to ask the sandwich artist if a sub can be toasted before placing your order.

  • Is there an extra charge for a toasted sub?

    No, there is no extra charge for a toasted sub at Jersey Mike’s.

  • Are cold subs still good at Jersey Mike’s?

    Yes, Jersey Mike’s is known for their fresh and delicious cold subs as well. It’s all a matter of personal preference.

  • Can I customize the toppings on my toasted sub?

    Yes, you can customize your toasted sub with any toppings you like. Just be sure to let the sandwich artist know what you want before they start toasting the sub.

  • Are Jersey Mike’s subs healthy?

    Like any fast food chain, the healthiness of Jersey Mike’s subs depends on what you order. Some subs are higher in calories and sodium than others, so it’s important to pay attention to nutrition information and make choices based on your dietary needs. However, Jersey Mike’s does offer several healthier options, such as their “sub in a tub” salads, that are lower in carbs and calories than their traditional subs.

Written : John Doe

Source: Yelp