Get the Perfect Crunch: How Jersey Mike’s Toasts Their Subs

Whether you’re on the go, taking a quick lunch break, or looking for a delicious meal at any time of day, the classic sub sandwich has been a staple of American cuisine for over a century. And when it comes to quality and flavor, few restaurants can compare to Jersey Mike’s.

Why Toasting Matters

One of the key elements that sets Jersey Mike’s apart from other sub shops is their commitment to toasting their subs. When you visit a Jersey Mike’s location, you’ll see their staff carefully and expertly toasting each sub to perfection. But why is toasting so important?

First and foremost, toasting a sub helps to enhance the flavor of the ingredients. When the bread is toasted, it becomes slightly crispy on the outside while remaining soft and chewy on the inside. This texture contrast can make even the most basic sub ingredients taste more complex and delicious.

Toasting also helps to ensure that the sub stays together when you take a bite. Soft bread can sometimes cause the sandwich to fall apart, leading to a mess and frustration for the eater. Toasted bread holds its shape better, making for a cleaner and more enjoyable eating experience.

The Toasting Process at Jersey Mike’s

So how exactly does Jersey Mike’s achieve that perfect crunch and flavor in their subs? It all starts with their specially-made bread, which is delivered fresh to each restaurant multiple times per day.

When you order a sub at Jersey Mike’s, the staff will first slice the bread to your desired length. They’ll then add your chosen ingredients, carefully layering them to achieve the best possible flavor combination. Finally, your sub will be placed onto a hot grill and toasted for just a few minutes until the bread is golden brown and crispy.

The result is a sub that is warm, crispy, and packed with flavor. Whether you’re enjoying a classic Philly cheesesteak or a vegetarian option like the Veggie, Jersey Mike’s toasted subs are sure to satisfy.

Customizing Your Toast

If you’re someone who likes things a little differently, Jersey Mike’s toast can be customized to your preferences. For example, if you prefer a softer bread, you can request that your sub be toasted for a shorter amount of time or at a lower temperature. On the other hand, if you’re someone who loves a really crunchy sub, simply ask for yours to be toasted for a bit longer or at a higher temperature.

Since each sub is toasted to order and with care, customization is easy and ensures that your sandwich will be exactly how you want it.

FAQs: The Most Common Questions About Jersey Mike’s Toasted Subs

Does Jersey Mike’s toast all of their subs?

Yes! At Jersey Mike’s, every sub is toasted unless otherwise specified. The toasting process is a key part of what makes Jersey Mike’s subs so delicious and flavorful.

Can I ask for my sub to not be toasted?

Absolutely! If you prefer your sub to be cold, simply let the staff know when you order and they’ll be happy to accommodate your request.

Why is the bread at Jersey Mike’s so good?

Jersey Mike’s bread is made fresh each day using a special recipe that has been perfected over decades. The bread is chewy, flavorful, and the perfect base for any sub sandwich.

What are some popular toasted subs at Jersey Mike’s?

While all of Jersey Mike’s toasted subs are delicious, a few standouts include the Original Italian (featuring provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami and pepperoni), the Club Supreme (turkey, roast beef, and bacon), and the Jersey Mike’s Famous Philly (thinly sliced steak, grilled onions and peppers, and melted white American cheese).

Can I customize my sub with different toasting instructions?

Absolutely! When you place your order, simply let the staff know how you’d like your sub to be toasted and they’ll ensure that it’s cooked to your exact specifications.


At Jersey Mike’s, the toasting process is an essential part of what makes their subs so delicious and satisfying. From the carefully-selected ingredients to the expert toasting process, each sub is made with care and attention to detail.

So next time you’re in the mood for a tasty sub, head to your nearest Jersey Mike’s location and enjoy the perfect crunch of a toasted sub.