The Perfect Toast: Inside Jersey Mike’s Secret Sub Making Method

Are you a sandwich lover who wants to know the secret behind the perfect toast for your subs? Look no further as Jersey Mike’s, one of the leading submarine sandwich chains in the United States, has a special method for toast that guarantees the perfect crunch and texture for your sandwich.

In this article, we will take a deep dive into the sub making process at Jersey Mike’s and uncover the secret method to their perfect toasting technique.

Jersey Mike’s Sub Making Process

Jersey Mike’s prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients in their sandwiches, which are made to order right in front of the customer. The sandwich making process at Jersey Mike’s consists of the following steps:

1. Bread Selection: Customers can choose from a variety of bread options, including white, wheat, rosemary parmesan, and gluten-free.

2. Meat and Cheese Selection: Customers can choose from a variety of meats and cheeses, including ham, turkey, roast beef, provolone, and American cheese.

3. Vegetable Selection: Customers can choose from a variety of vegetables, including lettuce, tomato, onions, peppers, and pickles.

4. Condiment Selection: Customers can choose from a variety of condiments, including mayo, mustard, oil, vinegar, and spices.

5. Sub Making: Once the customer has made their selections, the sandwich is made right in front of them. The bread is toasted, and the meats, cheeses, and vegetables are added, along with the condiments.

Jersey Mike’s Secret Toasting Technique

The secret to Jersey Mike’s perfect toast lies in its unique toasting technique. Unlike other sandwich chains that use a conveyor belt toaster, Jersey Mike’s uses a specialized toaster for its bread. The toaster is designed to toast the bread to perfection while keeping it chewy on the inside and crunchy on the outside.

The toasting process at Jersey Mike’s involves placing the bread in the toaster for a few seconds to heat it up, then toasting it again for a short period until it reaches the perfect level of crispiness. The bread is then taken out of the toaster and used immediately to make the sandwich.

Why Does Jersey Mike’s Use a Specialized Toaster?

Jersey Mike’s uses a specialized toaster because it allows the bread to be toasted evenly without being overcooked or burned. The toaster uses infrared heat to toast the bread, which is more precise than traditional toaster ovens that rely on convection heat. This precision ensures that the bread is toasted perfectly every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Jersey Mike’s Toast All of Their Subs?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s toasts all of their subs unless the customer specifically requests that the bread not be toasted.

Can You Get Your Bread Toasted to Your Liking?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s allows customers to request their bread to be toasted to their liking. Whether you like your bread lightly toasted or extra crispy, Jersey Mike’s will make it just the way you want it.

Can You Get a Cold Sandwich at Jersey Mike’s?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s offers cold sandwiches for customers who prefer their subs without toasting. Cold sandwiches are assembled just like the toasted sandwiches, with fresh bread and high-quality ingredients.

Does Jersey Mike’s Use Fresh Bread?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s uses fresh bread for all of their sandwiches. The bread is baked fresh every day and delivered to each store, ensuring that the bread is always fresh and of the highest quality.

Does Jersey Mike’s Offer Gluten-Free Bread?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s offers gluten-free bread for customers who have gluten sensitivities or allergies. The gluten-free bread is toasted just like the regular bread, ensuring that it is just as delicious and satisfying.


In conclusion, Jersey Mike’s uses a specialized toasting technique to guarantee the perfect texture and crunch for their sandwiches. Their unique approach to toasting ensures that the bread is evenly toasted and perfectly crispy on the outside while remaining chewy on the inside. Whether you prefer your bread lightly toasted or extra crispy, Jersey Mike’s will make it just the way you like it. So next time you visit Jersey Mike’s, be sure to try their toasted subs and taste the difference for yourself!