The Ultimate Guide to Jersey Mikes Subs Toast or No

The Ultimate Guide to Jersey Mike’s Subs: Toast or No Toast?

Jersey Mike’s Subs is one of the most popular sandwich chains worldwide. It is famous for preparing fresh sandwiches that come in different sizes and varieties to cater to the varying palates of its customers. One of the most frequently debated topics among Jersey Mike’s Subs customers is whether to have their subs toasted or not. Toasted subs have a crispy texture that can be quite satisfying, while non-toasted subs retain the soft, fluffy texture of the bread. This guide will help you determine whether to go for toasted or non-toasted Jersey Mike’s Subs.

Why Toasting Matters

Toasting the bread on a sandwich has been a popular practice for centuries. The practice began as a way to make stale bread more palatable. However, with time, toasting has become an art, and its popularity has continued to rise. Toasting bread creates a crispy layer on the outside while keeping the bread soft and moist on the inside. This texture enhances the flavors of the sandwich and provides a satisfying crunch.

What is a toasted sub?

A toasted sub is a sandwich that has been heated in an oven or a toaster. The bread is placed in the oven for a specified time, and when it comes out, it has a crispy layer on the outside while remaining soft on the inside. This preparation technique is commonly used in sandwich shops to provide a unique texture to the bread.

What is a non-toasted sub?

A non-toasted sub is a sandwich that has not been heated in any way. The bread remains soft and fluffy, retaining the natural taste and texture of the bread.

The Benefits of Toasting Your Sub

Although non-toasted subs may appeal to some customers, toasted subs have a few benefits that are worth considering.

1. Crispy Texture

Toasting the bread gives the sandwich a crispy texture that can be quite satisfying. The outer crust is crunchy, while the inside remains soft and fluffy. This texture enhances the overall flavor of the sandwich, making it more enjoyable.

2. Warmer Sandwich

Toasting the bread also warms the sandwich, making it more enjoyable to eat, especially during colder months. The warm temperature of the bread complements the filling of the sandwich, making it tastier.

3. Longer Shelf life

Toasting the bread also extends the shelf life of the sandwich. Whereas a non-toasted sandwich can become soggy after a few hours, a toasted sandwich can remain fresh for more extended periods. This is because the heat of the toasting process removes the moisture from the bread, making it less likely to become stale.

The Drawbacks of Toasting Your Sub

Toasting a sandwich may improve its texture, but it also has some drawbacks that could turn some customers away.

1. Unpredictable Results

Toasting a sandwich can be unpredictable, and sometimes a customer’s preference may not align with the sandwich shop’s toasting process. Some customers may want their bread to be toasted lightly, while others may prefer their bread to be slightly more toasted. It is also worth noting that different sandwich sizes and styles may require different toasting times, making it challenging for some sandwich shops to achieve the desired results consistently.

2. Less Fresh Vegetables

Toasting a sandwich can also have an impact on the freshness of the vegetables. Toasting can cause the vegetables to become wilted or soft, which can significantly affect the flavor and texture of the sandwich. For this reason, some customers prefer their subs to be made with raw vegetables, which increases the nutritional value and overall freshness of the sandwich.

3. Price

Toasted subs are generally more expensive than non-toasted subs. This is because they require more time and energy to prepare than non-toasted subs. Some customers may be put off the extra cost and may choose to go for a non-toasted sub instead.


Does Jersey Mike’s toast their subs?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s does toast their subs. You can request a toasted sandwich, and it will come out with a crispy texture.

Can I get my Jersey Mike’s sub not toasted?

Yes, you can get your Jersey Mike’s sub not toasted. All you have to do is request it, and the sandwich maker will prepare it without toasting.

Why does Jersey Mike’s toast their subs?

Jersey Mike’s toasts their subs to provide customers with a unique and satisfying texture. Toasting the bread also helps to warm the sandwich and extend its shelf life.

How much does it cost to get a toasted sandwich at Jersey Mike’s?

Toasted subs at Jersey Mike’s are generally more expensive than non-toasted subs. However, the cost may vary depending on the size and style of the sandwich.


When it comes to deciding whether to go for a toasted or non-toasted Jersey Mike’s sub, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. Toasting a sandwich has its advantages and drawbacks, and each customer’s preference may differ. Whether you prefer your sub toasted to a crisp or soft and fluffy, Jersey Mike’s has got you covered. Visit any of their locations and enjoy a fresh, delicious sub made just the way you like it.