To Toast or Not to Toast Debating Jersey Mikes Subs

To Toast or Not to Toast: Debating Jersey Mike’s Subs

Jersey Mike’s subs are among the most famous sub sandwiches in the United States. These subs come in a variety of flavors, and customers have different preferences when it comes to toasting them.

Some people argue that toasting the subs ruins the texture and flavor, while others say that it enhances the taste. In this article, we will discuss the various arguments for and against toasting subs at Jersey Mike’s.

Arguments for Toasting

There are several reasons why people prefer toasting their sub sandwiches at Jersey Mike’s. One of the primary arguments is that it gives the bread a crunchy texture, which complements the filling. Toasting is particularly helpful when the ingredients are cold or wet, and the bread needs to hold its shape.

Additionally, toasting the bread helps to lock in the flavors and juices of the fillings, especially the meat. The heat from the toaster produces a warm, cozy feeling in the mouth, which is perfect for chilly days.

Arguments against Toasting

While toasting has its benefits, some customers feel that it detracts from the Jersey Mike’s experience. One of the primary arguments against toasting is that it removes the freshness from the bread, making it stale and hard to chew.

Others argue that the toasted bread overpowers the flavors and textures of the filling, making it difficult to taste the individual ingredients. Some customers say that they prefer the cold subs because they feel that the ingredients have a fresher, more natural taste when not toasted.

The Case for Customization

One of the great things about Jersey Mike’s is that customers have the option to customize their subs. Whether you prefer toasted, cold, or partially toasted bread, Jersey Mike’s allows you to tailor your sandwich to your liking.

Customers can choose from a range of ingredients, including meats, cheeses, vegetables, and condiments, to create a personalized sandwich that satisfies their cravings. The ability to customize also means that you can experiment with toasted and cold versions of your favorite subs and pick the one that works best for you.

The Verdict: To Toast or Not to Toast?

So, should you toast your Jersey Mike’s subs or not? The answer is entirely up to you. There is no right or wrong way to enjoy a Jersey Mike’s sub sandwich. The important thing is to find what works for you and stick with it.

If you prefer the warm, crispy texture of toasted bread and enjoy the enhanced flavor that toasting can bring, then all means, go for it. On the other hand, if you prefer the natural, fresh taste of the ingredients and enjoy the cold sub experience, then there’s nothing wrong with opting for a cold sandwich.

At the end of the day, the quality of the ingredients and the overall taste and texture of the sub are the most important factors. Jersey Mike’s delivers on both counts, whether you choose to toast your sandwich or not.


Here are some frequently asked questions about the toasting debate at Jersey Mike’s.

Does Jersey Mike’s toast subs default?

No, Jersey Mike’s does not toast subs default. It is entirely up to the customer to choose whether they want their sandwich toasted or not.

Can I ask for a partially-toasted sub?

Yes, you can ask for a partially toasted sub. Jersey Mike’s offers a range of toasting options, so you can customize your sandwich to your liking.

What’s the best way to reheat a Jersey Mike’s sub?

The best way to reheat a Jersey Mike’s sub is to put it in the oven or a toaster oven for a few minutes. This will warm up the bread and filling without making it too hot.

Is it possible to get a cold sub with melted cheese?

Yes, it is possible to get a cold sub with melted cheese at Jersey Mike’s. The cheese can be added to the sandwich after it has been assembled.

What’s the most popular sub at Jersey Mike’s?

The most popular sub at Jersey Mike’s is the #13, The Original Italian. It features provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni.


In conclusion, the toasting debate at Jersey Mike’s is a matter of personal preference. Whether you prefer the warmth and crunch of toasted bread or the freshness of cold ingredients, Jersey Mike’s has a range of options to suit your taste. The most important thing is to enjoy your sandwich, no matter how you choose to have it. So, the next time you’re at Jersey Mike’s, try something new and see what works best for you.