To Toast or Not to Toast: The Jersey Mike’s Debate

Jersey Mike’s is one of the most popular fast food restaurants in America, known for its fresh and delicious subs. However, one of the most contentious issues amongst fans of the popular eatery is whether the sandwiches should be toasted or served cold. This debate has made its way into forums, discussion boards, and even social media, with fans on both sides of the issue arguing fiercely for their preferred method of serving subs. This article will delve into the Jersey Mike’s debate, exploring the arguments for and against toasting, and ultimately determine which method is better.

Arguments for Toasted Subs

There are several arguments in favor of toasting sub sandwiches. One of the most common reasons cited is that toasting adds a crunchy texture to the sandwich, which provides an additional layer of flavor and enjoyment. Toasting also creates a warm sandwich, which can be a welcome treat during colder weather. Additionally, toasting can help to melt cheese and other toppings, enhancing the overall flavor profile of the sandwich.

Another argument in favor of toasting subs is that it allows the bread to hold up better when fillings are added. When a sandwich is toasted, the bread is able to withstand the moisture and weight of the sandwich fillings, preventing the bread from becoming soggy or falling apart. This makes it easier to eat the sandwich and ensures that its flavors will be evenly distributed throughout each bite.

Arguments for Cold Subs

On the other side of the debate, some people argue that subs should be served cold, rather than toasted. One major reason for this is the belief that the bread and fillings are fresher when served cold. Bread that is toasted may be too tough or stale, detracting from the overall experience of the sandwich. Additionally, some fillings (such as lettuce and tomatoes) may become wilted or lose their flavor if they are heated up.

Another argument for cold subs is that they are already perfect as they are! In some people’s opinions, the sandwich ingredients are flavorful enough on their own, without the need for any additional heat or texture. They argue that toasting, in fact, distracts from the original taste of the sandwich, reducing its appeal and overall satisfaction for the eater.

The Jersey Mike’s Experience

At Jersey Mike’s, the toasting decision is largely left up to the customer. When placing an order, customers can choose to have their subs served hot or cold, depending on their personal preferences. Additionally, select sandwiches are only available toasted or cold, with ingredients that are best enhanced one or the other preparation method.

Overall, the Jersey Mike’s experience is widely regarded as a positive one, with customers enjoying the quality and freshness of the restaurant’s ingredients. The decision to toast or not to toast, therefore, is largely a matter of personal taste and preference, rather than a fundamental difference in the quality of the subs

FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions

1) Are Jersey Mike’s subs better toasted or cold?

There is no definitive answer to this question. It ultimately comes down to personal taste and preference.

2) what are the most popular sandwiches at Jersey Mike’s?

Jersey Mike’s most popular sandwiches include the “Sub in a Tub”, “The Original Italian,” and “Turkey Breast and Provolone.”

3) What ingredients are best suited for toasting versus serving cold?

Cheese, meatballs, and steak are all great options to have toasted, while vegetables, cold cuts, and seafood tend to be better suited for serving cold.

4) How many Jersey Mike’s stores are there in the U.S.?

As of 2021, Jersey Mike’s has over 2,500 stores in the United States.


When it comes to subs, everyone has their own opinion on the toasting debate. However, at Jersey Mike’s, customers can experience the best of both worlds, with the freedom to choose whether their subs are served hot or cold. Whether you prefer the crunch and warmth that toasting provides, or the natural freshness of a cold sandwich, Jersey Mike’s is sure to have the perfect sub to satisfy your cravings.