To Toast or Not to Toast The Jersey Mikes Debate

To Toast or Not to Toast? The Jersey Mike’s Debate

When it comes to enjoying a sandwich at Jersey Mike’s, one of the main debates that have arisen amongst customers is whether to toast or not to toast their subs. At the heart of the debate is the question of personal preference as to whether toasting the sandwich improves its flavor or not.

Jersey Mike’s has managed to create a loyal fan base of customers who attest to the quality and freshness of their subs. With over 2,000 locations across the United States, it has become a go-to spot for many people looking for a quick and delicious sandwich. But what is it about toasting that has caused so much debate?

This article will explore why toasting sub bread at Jersey Mike’s has become such a divisive issue among customers, and whether toasting your sub is truly the best choice.

Why Do Some People Toast Their Subs at Jersey Mike’s?

Toasting sandwich bread has been a common practice for many years. It is believed to improve the overall flavor and texture of the sandwich crisping the bread and enhancing its flavor. Toasting the bread can also help to melt the cheese and other toppings, which can improve the consistency and taste of the sandwich.

For many customers at Jersey Mike’s, toasting their sub is a must. They believe that it’s the only way to bring out the full flavor and quality of the sandwich. Others will argue that it is unnecessary and defeats the purpose of having fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Why Don’t Some People Toast Their Subs?

For those who prefer their sandwich bread untoasted, it’s all about the texture. They argue that toasting the bread can make it too crunchy and take away from the natural softness of the bread. Also, for those with sensitive teeth, toasted bread can be difficult to chew and uncomfortable to eat.

Additionally, some customers believe that toasting the sandwich takes away from the fresh flavor of the ingredients. Jersey Mike’s prides itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients that are already packed with flavor. Toasting the sandwich can overpower those flavors and make everything taste the same.

Does Toasting Your Sub Affect Its Nutritional Content?

While toasting your sub may improve its texture and taste, it does not affect its nutritional content. The amount of calories and nutrients in a sub will not differ due to toasting the bread.

However, it’s important to note that the toppings you choose for your sandwich can impact the overall nutritional value. Choosing healthier toppings such as fresh vegetables over processed meats and cheeses will benefit your diet regardless of whether or not you choose to toast your bread.


Does Jersey Mike’s Offer Both Toasted and Untoasted Bread?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s offers both toasted and untoasted bread options for their subs. Customers are able to customize their sandwiches to their liking, including their choice of bread, toppings, and condiments.

Is Toasting the Bread an Extra Charge at Jersey Mike’s?

No, toasting your bread at Jersey Mike’s is not an additional charge. The price of the sandwich remains the same regardless of whether you choose to toast your bread or not.

Can You Request a Sandwich to Be Toasted or Untoasted at Jersey Mike’s?

Yes, customers are allowed to request their sandwiches to be toasted or untoasted at Jersey Mike’s. The staff at Jersey Mike’s will do their best to accommodate your request and make your sandwich the way you like it.


Ultimately, the decision to toast your sandwich at Jersey Mike’s comes down to personal preference. If you enjoy the added crunch and flavor that toasting provides, then go for it. If you prefer the softness and freshness of untoasted bread, then that is equally acceptable.

Regardless of the debate over toasting, the quality and freshness of Jersey Mike’s subs are exceptional. Customers can enjoy their sandwiches any way they like them, with a wide range of freshly-cut vegetables, meats, and cheeses to choose from. So whether you’re a toasting believer or a purist, you can always count on Jersey Mike’s for a delicious sandwich.

Jersey Mike’s Menu