Toast or Not to Toast The Debate Over Jersey Mikes

Toast or Not to Toast: The Debate Over Jersey Mike’s Subs

When it comes to sandwiches, there are a lot of important debates to be had. Mayo or mustard? Pickles or no pickles? But one of the most divisive sandwich controversies has to do with whether or not a sub should be toasted. Some people swear toasted bread, arguing that it adds a delicious crunch and enhances the flavors of the sandwich fillings. Others prefer their subs cold, arguing that toasting makes the bread too hard and overpowers the ingredients inside. And then there are people who don’t really care either way.

The Debate Over Jersey Mike’s

One sandwich shop that’s at the center of this debate is Jersey Mike’s, a popular chain with locations across the United States. The chain is known for its fresh ingredients, high-quality meats, and made-to-order subs. But when it comes to toasting those subs, opinions are split.

Some customers argue that Jersey Mike’s should always toast its subs. They say that the heat brings out the best in the bread and meat, creating a mouth-watering sandwich that’s second to none. Others disagree, saying that toasting ruins the delicate balance of flavors and textures that make a great sub. Some even go so far as to say that toasting turns the bread into cardboard, making the sandwich practically inedible.

The Case for Toasting

For those who swear toasted subs, there are plenty of good reasons to argue in favor of toasting. One of the main benefits is that toasting creates a satisfying crunch that complements the soft, chewy interior of the bread. This crunch also helps keep the ingredients from sliding around or falling out of the sandwich, making for a more enjoyable eating experience.

Additionally, toasting can enhance the flavors of the sandwich fillings. The heat from the toasting process can bring out the natural sweetness or smokiness of the meats and cheeses, making them taste more complex and satisfying. It can also add a slight char or caramelization to the bread, giving it a slightly nutty, toasty flavor that’s hard to resist.

The Case Against Toasting

But for those who prefer their subs cold, there are just as many convincing arguments against toasting. One of the main concerns is that toasting can dry out the bread, making it hard and crumbly. This can overwhelm the fillings, making them seem dry or bland in comparison.

Toasting can also change the texture of the sandwich in unwanted ways. Depending on the bread and fillings used, toasting can create a sandwich that’s overly crunchy or even burnt. This can mask the delicate flavors and textures of the ingredients, making the sandwich seem one-dimensional.

The Jersey Mike’s Approach

So what’s Jersey Mike’s take on this divisive issue? The chain actually leaves the decision up to the customer. When you order a sub at Jersey Mike’s, you can choose to have it toasted or served cold. This means that everyone can get their sandwich just the way they like it.

Additionally, Jersey Mike’s uses high-quality bread and ingredients to ensure that their subs taste great, regardless of whether or not they’re toasted. The company takes pride in its sourcing practices and commitment to freshness, which can help make up for any potential loss of flavor or texture caused toasting.


Does Jersey Mike’s toast subs?

Yes, but it’s up to the customer whether they want their sub toasted or served cold.

Is toasting better than not toasting?

It depends on your personal preferences. Some people love the extra crunch and flavor that toasting provides, while others prefer a more soft, delicate sandwich.

Does toasting dry out the bread?

It can, depending on the type of bread and how long it’s toasted for. But many people find that the slight dryness and crunch is part of what makes a toasted sandwich so satisfying.

What types of bread does Jersey Mike’s use for its subs?

Jersey Mike’s uses a variety of different breads, including white, wheat, and rosemary parmesan. All of their breads are made fresh daily and contain no artificial preservatives or additives.

What other ingredients does Jersey Mike’s use in its subs?

Jersey Mike’s uses high-quality meats and cheeses, fresh vegetables, and a variety of sauces and seasonings to create its subs. The chain is known for its commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.

The Bottom Line

At the end of the day, whether or not to toast a sub is a matter of personal preference. Some people will always prefer a cold, soft sandwich, while others will always opt for the crunch and flavor of a toasted sub. But what’s great about Jersey Mike’s is that everyone can get the sandwich they want. Whether you’re in the mood for something crispy and toasty, or soft and delicate, Jersey Mike’s has got you covered.