Toasting to Perfection: Jersey Mike’s Secret to Delicious Subs Unveiled

If you’re a sub sandwich lover, chances are you’ve already visited Jersey Mike’s at least once. The chain has been serving their famous subs since 1956, and today, it has over 2,000 locations worldwide. One of the things that sets Jersey Mike’s apart from other sub shops is their commitment to toasting their subs. But what’s their secret to making their subs so irresistibly delicious? In this article, we’ll unveil the mystery behind Jersey Mike’s toasting technique and share some tips on how to make your own subs at home.

The Science of Toasting

Have you ever wondered why toasted bread tastes better than untoasted bread? The answer lies in the chemical reactions that take place during toasting. When bread is toasted, the heat causes the Maillard reaction to occur. This process causes the carbohydrates and proteins in the bread to break down into new compounds that give the bread a deeper flavor and a more complex aroma. The toasting process also generates new colors and textures, making the bread crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

What Makes Jersey Mike’s Toasting Technique Unique?

Jersey Mike’s toasting technique is unique because it uses a special oven called a Merrychef oven. This oven is designed to toast subs quickly and evenly, without drying out the bread or overcooking the meat. The Merrychef oven uses a combination of microwave and convection technology, which ensures that the subs are perfectly toasted in just 12 seconds.

Another key to Jersey Mike’s success is the quality of their ingredients. All of their subs are made with freshly baked bread, high-quality meats, and fresh vegetables. When you combine these high-quality ingredients with the perfect toasting technique, you get a sandwich that is bursting with flavor and texture.

The Benefits of Toasting Subs

Toasting subs has several benefits, both in terms of flavor and texture. Here are some of the main benefits of toasting subs:

  • Enhanced flavor: As previously mentioned, toasting increases the depth and complexity of the bread’s flavor.
  • Improved texture: Toasted bread has a crispy exterior and a soft interior, giving the sandwich a nice contrast in texture.
  • Improved food safety: Toasting subs can help kill any bacteria that may be present in the ingredients.
  • Extended shelf life: Toasting can help preserve the freshness of the bread and ingredients, making the sandwich last longer.

How to Make Your Own Toasted Subs at Home

If you’re a fan of Jersey Mike’s subs, you may want to try making your own at home. Here are some tips on how to toast your subs to perfection:

  • Choose high-quality ingredients: Use fresh bread, high-quality meats, and fresh vegetables for the best flavor.
  • Preheat your oven: Make sure your oven is preheated to the correct temperature before toasting your subs.
  • Use a toaster oven or a regular oven: If you don’t have access to a Merrychef oven, you can still toast your subs in a toaster oven or a regular oven. Just make sure to watch them closely to prevent over-toasting.
  • Be creative: Don’t be afraid to experiment with different ingredients and flavors to create your own unique subs.


Does Jersey Mike’s Toast Subs?

Yes, Jersey Mike’s toasts their subs to perfection using a Merrychef oven, which ensures that the subs are evenly toasted and bursting with flavor.

What Makes Jersey Mike’s Subs So Delicious?

Jersey Mike’s subs are made with high-quality ingredients, including fresh-baked bread, premium meats, and fresh vegetables. They are also toasted to perfection using a special oven that ensures they are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

Can You Toast Subs in a Regular Oven?

Yes, you can toast subs in a regular oven. Just make sure to preheat the oven to the correct temperature and keep an eye on the subs to prevent over-toasting.

How Long Does it Take to Toast a Sub?

At Jersey Mike’s, it takes just 12 seconds to toast a sub to perfection using their Merrychef oven. If you’re using a regular oven, it may take a little longer, depending on the temperature and the size of the sub.


Jersey Mike’s toasting technique is a key part of what makes their subs so delicious. By using high-quality ingredients and the perfect toasting method, they’ve created a sub that is bursting with flavor and texture. If you’re a fan of Jersey Mike’s subs, try making your own at home using these tips to achieve the perfect toasting experience.